Okay, tough love time.
Everyone thinks of Your Social Team only as the Instagram experts. The trends. The Reels. The red carpet at The Reelies. And yes, guilty.
But here's what's actually running our business behind the scenes: our email list. It has over 30,000 people on it, and it truly is a sales machine.
Every Trend Drop, every launch, every "doors are open!" moment starts in the inbox. Instagram gets people to say hi. Email is where they become customers.
So today I'm showing you how we grew our email list from zero, what we send every week, and the exact monthly plan you can copy.
First of all, let’s get this out of the way:
the best email platform for small business owners an creators who care about Aesthetic is flodesk
Flodesk has two plans, Unlimited Email and Unlimited Everything. Both include unlimited subscribers and unlimited emails for one flat price.
Unlimited Email starts at $38 a month and Unlimited Everything starts at $79 a month, billed annually. Your price stays the same whether you have 500 subscribers or 50,000, which is what makes Flodesk so affordable in the long run.
Quick heads up: I'm a Flodesk Partner, so if you sign up through my link, I may earn a commission.
Why does an Instagram brand care so much about email?
Because social media is rented land, and email is land you own.
We have over 150,000 followers across our social accounts. I love every single one of them. But one glitch, one policy change, one hacked account, and poof, I could lose access to all of them overnight, with no way to reach them anywhere else.
Your email list is different. It's yours.
You can download it, back it up, and take it with you if you ever switch platforms.
And here's the part that still makes me laugh: our email list is less than half the size of our Instagram following. But our emails bring in about double the sales.
Want proof? One day, I posted a carousel, shared a Story, and sent a newsletter, all on the same day. Here's what happened:
Carousel: 18 link requests
Story: 31 clicks
Newsletter: 244 clicks
And my email list was only about a third the size of my Instagram. Why? A few reasons.
On social, it's normal for a post to reach less than 10% of your followers. With email, about 85% of your list will at least see your name and subject line in their inbox. On Instagram, people are scrolling fast, half-watching, and DMing their friends. When someone opens your email, you have their full attention. And you have room for pictures and, wink wink, links.
Plus, people buy from emails about 3x faster than from social media.
Our favorite vanity metric is money in the bank. That's why email is the center of our business, even though we're a social brand.
One quick tip before we go further: back up your list every month. Download it from Flodesk and save it to your Google Drive or computer. Think of it as insurance for your contacts.
How did we grow our email list to 30,000 subscribers?
We started from zero, one person at a time, and then gave people a really good freebie in exchange for their email.
You do not need thousands of followers or a viral Reel to build an email list. Our very first subscribers were people who already knew us:
Past clients.
People who were always in our DMs.
People who commented on everything.
We just asked them if they wanted to join. Then we started creating freebies, and that's when things really took off.
Today, our biggest list builder is the comment trigger. Someone watches a Reel, comments a word, and ManyChat sends them a DM with a link. That link takes them to a form or landing page, they drop in their email, and the freebie lands in their inbox.
It works because it's fast. Nobody has to leave the app, hunt for the link in bio, or remember us later. Comment, tap, done.
What should my first freebie be?
Go find your Instagram carousel with the most saves. That's your freebie.
Those saves are your audience telling you, "This is useful, I want to keep it." So turn each slide into a section of a simple guide, turn your tips into a checklist, or record a quick video walking through it. Done.
Please keep it simple. We have some free guides that are pretty big, because we have a team and the time to make it, but we also have freebies that took us only an hour to make. Yours can be a one-page Google Doc.
Two more things I've learned.
First, skip the discount code as your freebie. A discount only gets the people who were ready to buy today, and that's usually a tiny slice of your audience.
Second, timely freebies get more sign-ups. Something like "Get Your Business Holiday-Ready" gets grabbed right now instead of saved for later.
Whatever you make, focus on solving one problem so people get a quick win. And if you're a service business, your freebie can be a free 1:1 call. That's a great place to start.
Where should I share my email sign-up form?
Everywhere your people already hang out, for us that looks like:
Our Instagram bio links to a landing page.
Our ManyChat DMs send people straight to a form.
Our Pinterest pins go to our blog posts, and every blog post has a form tucked inside.
And for you that could look the same, plus:
When you're a guest on a podcast, ask the host to link your freebie instead of your homepage.
And on your website, add a form to your most popular blog posts and your footer.
Make a free resources page on your website with all your freebies in one spot, and link to it from your footer.
Try a friendly pop-up that only shows after someone has been reading a blog post for a bit. No one likes a pop-up in their face the second they land.
Write a guest post for a blog your people already read, and link to your freebie in your bio there.
Team up with other business owners on a free bundle, summit, or workshop where everyone shares the sign-up.
How do I get my first 100 email subscribers?
Ask people. Personally. One at a time. I know, it sounds too simple. But it works so much better than another "join my list!" post if you are just getting started
And if you're thinking, "Okay, that works for you, but I'm just starting out," let me show you something. Back in 2017, I sent one email to 141 people. That one email brought in $357.39 in sales.
You do not need a big list. You just need to email them.
Start by writing down 10 people who would love what you share. Then DM them and ask if they want to join. After that, send a personal DM to 5 people a day who engage with your content. Something like:
"Hey! I noticed you liked my post about [topic]. I'm sharing more about this in my email community. Want me to send you the link?"
A few other ideas that work great for small accounts:
tell your followers something exciting is coming tomorrow, but only in your email.
Host a free 30-minute workshop that's just for subscribers.
Or share 5 tips in a carousel and save the best one, tip #6, for people on your list.
Every time someone buys from you, invite them to join your email list too.
Share your sign-up link in your Instagram Stories often, not just once. People miss things!
What should my welcome email say?
Thank them, remind them what they signed up for, and give them a quick win.
Your welcome email is like opening the front door of your digital home, so here is a winning format you can copy:
Say thank you for joining.
Remind them why they joined, and give them the freebie link. S
hare one short paragraph about you and your business.
Tell them what kind of emails they'll get from you.
Then give them one quick win, like a helpful tip or resource they can use today.
In Flodesk, this all runs on its own with a workflow. Someone signs up, the welcome email goes out, and nobody joins your list and hears crickets.
What should I send my email list every week?
You don't need brand new content every week. Pick from five types of emails your subscribers actually want.
Value emails. Take your best social posts or blog posts, the ones with the most saves or comments, and turn them into emails. They're already proven winners.
Exclusive content. Share a tip or resource that only your email list gets. This is what makes your list feel like a VIP club, because it is.
Another freebie. Surprise them with a new resource. They joined for good stuff, so give them more of it.
Special offers. Share deals that only your email list gets. These people already like you, so they're more likely to buy.
Behind the scenes. Show them what you're working on or how you do things. This is how people start to feel connected to you.
Your newest blog post. Just wrote something great? Send it to your list too. Not everyone checks your blog.
News in your niche. Talk about what's happening in your industry and what it means for your people.
And yes, we sell in our emails. Be salesy! Showing up in the inbox with links is half the battle to selling more. If you never mention what you offer, people honestly forget you sell anything.
How do I write emails people actually open and click?
Keep it short, add one image, and always add a link.
Keep your subject lines short, curious, and honest. Your subject line is what makes people open. Make them curious, but never trick them.
Add one image per email. It breaks up the text and makes your email way easier to read.
Always link your offers, blog posts, or freebies. The more people click, the better.
Email once a week if you can. Even a short email counts. Showing up is the whole game.
Ready to start and grow your email list with Flodesk?
Start with one freebie, one form, and one email a week. That's honestly all it takes to get going. And if you want to make it WAY easier, I totally recommend Flodesk. It is super user-friendly AND unlike other email marketing platforms, Flodesk is one flat price with unlimited subscribers and unlimited emails, so growing your list never grows your bill.
P.S. I am a Flodesk partner, so if you sign up I will earn a small commission at no additional cost to you, but I only recommend products I have vetted and truly love.
Photo: KVC Photography
About Manu Muraro
Manu Muraro is the founder of Your Social Team, a content marketing brand helping small business owners grow through strategic email marketing and Instagram content.
She’s the creator of Your Template Club, one of the first Canva template subscriptions designed for Instagram, and the founder of Your Inbox Team, a weekly email marketing membership that helps entrepreneurs send consistent, high-converting emails in under 15 minutes.
Manu is also the creator of The Reelies Awards, the first award show celebrating Small Business Owners and Creators’ creativity and originality in Instagram Reels.
A former creative strategist at Cartoon Network, Manu brings award-winning experience to everything she creates — from viral Reels to done-for-you content that saves time and drives results.
👉 Follow Manu at Your Social Team on Instagram